Plymouth/Terryville Housing Market Report by The Via Domus Team

CT Real Estate Housing Market Report | June–July 2025

Plymouth | Terryville

Key Insights for Buyers and Sellers

The combined area of Plymouth and Terryville offers a mixed-market dynamic. Plymouth remains a seller’s market, though slightly cooling, while Terryville has transitioned to a neutral market, creating opportunities for both buyers and sellers depending on their strategy and timing.

Market Performance Overview

Plymouth (June 2025)

  • Median sale price: $300,000, down 1.8% year-over-year

  • Median price per sq ft: $201

  • Active listings fell 16.7% from May to 35 homes

  • 67% of June’s sales closed above asking price; 33% under ask

Terryville (June 2025)

  • Median sale price: $295,500, down 4.4% YoY

  • Price per sq ft: $200

  • Active listings dropped ~21.9% to 25 homes

  • Market shifted to neutral with about half of homes selling below or above ask, indicating balance

Zillow Data Summary

  • Plymouth’s average home value: $322,452, up 3.0% YoY

  • Terryville’s average value: $316,673, up 3.3% YoY

Inventory & Market Conditions

In Plymouth, the available housing supply is very tight, with only 35 active listings in June (a 17% drop from May) Rocket Mortgage. Homes continue to attract offers above listing price, with 67% closing over ask.

Terryville is more balanced: listing levels dropped to 25 active homes, and while buyer interest remains, price gaps and speed of sales have cooled—average days on market hover around 13 days, indicating a moderate pace .

Market Insights & Buyer/Seller Considerations

Buyers in Plymouth:

  • Expect competition—over two-thirds of homes sell above ask.

  • Pre-approval and readiness are critical; consider value gaps and timing.

Buyers in Terryville:

  • More room to negotiate; nearly half of homes sold below asking price.

  • Still beneficial to be prepared—sellers list strategically in this neutral market.

Sellers in Plymouth:

  • Take advantage of low inventory and strong buyer interest.

  • Well-priced listings can receive multiple offers; staging and accurate pricing are key.

Sellers in Terryville:

  • Neutral market means pricing smart is vital—you'll likely get attention but negotiation is expected.

  • Homes still sell relatively quickly (~13 days) if priced and positioned well.

Popular Places to Visit in Plymouth/Terryville

  • Lock Museum of America (Terryville) – A gem highlighting local craftsmanship and history

  • Farmington River & Heritage Trails – Outdoor recreation and scenic beauty in both towns.

  • Downtown Plymouth & Terryville Main Streets – Local shops, cafés, and community character.

  • Plymouth Historical Districts – Featuring charming architecture and seasonal events.

  • Nearby Outdoor Spaces – Explore trail networks, greenways, and riverside parks spanning the area.

What This Means for You

Buyers:

  • In Plymouth, speed and financial readiness are essential.

  • In Terryville, you’ll find negotiation room—savers on stress and price.

Sellers:

  • In Plymouth, it's prime time—your home can sell fast and at strong terms.

  • In Terryville, analysis and accurate pricing will yield solid results, even without bidding wars.

Bottom Line

Plymouth continues favoring sellers, though prices are slightly down—aggressive pricing and preparation will still yield results. Terryville offers a more balanced environment allowing for negotiation. Whether buying or selling, this region presents well-defined opportunities with the right approach.

Ready to Make Your Move? Let’s Talk

Whether you are considering selling your home or buying in Plymouth or Terryville, The Via Domus Team is here to guide you through every step of the process. With our award-winning service and in-depth market expertise, we will help you navigate the Plymouth and Terryville real estate markets with confidence.

Reach out today for a complimentary seller or buyer consultation.
Helping You Find (and Sell) the Way Home.

Contact us for more market information on the Plymouth or Terryville markets, or if there is another town you would like housing market information on.